http://dennyhatch.blogspot.com/2020/09/108-selling-air-travel-amid-covid-19.html
#108 Blog Post – Tuesday, September 8, 2020
Posted by Denny Hatch
The Ultimate Marketing Challenge:
Selling Air Travel Amid Covid-19
After 6 months of self-inflicted Covid-19 isolation, Peggy and I would love to jump on a jet and fly off to one of the two trips we canceled last February. Looking at the current pandemic data worldwide, the answer is NFW.
However...
What if a
family emergency on the West Coast or across the globe suddenly required our presence?
How could the airlines make me feel safe and emotionally comfortable amidst the crush of humanity in the airport and later inside an Airbus A-321 hurtling at 520 MPH at 35,000 feet altitude—squeezed into an 11'-6"-wide tube sitting immobile 3-aisle-3 across—for six-to-ten hours amidst 186 other passengers any one of whom could be a highly contagious spreader of the killer Covid-19?
What triggered this post was the P.R. pitch from a flak at The Aviation Agency dot com, where business is probably very slow. From her email:
Imagine in the future you want to fly to Florida. One airline is $350, another $450. But the more expensive one has spent the last 18 months convincing you that their Coronavirus protocols are the best in the industry. They retrained their staff, replaced all the seats with antimicrobial fabric, they doubled the air filtration system, etc. Wouldn’t you pay the extra $100 if it made you feel safer?
Troy Hayes, Creative Director of The Aviation Agency, thinks you would. And so would he. Please reach out if you would like to speak with Troy about his insights on why now is the time for airlines to save their brand. Not make quarterly numbers. Thanks! —Lauren Smith September 1, 2020
Lauren’s Fascinating Marketing Challenge Got My Juices Flowing!
When Covid-19 eventually disappears—or a vaccine is widely distributed and proven effective—another pandemic will probably show up. Call it eBozo, London Fluzie or MOO-GOO-GAI-PANdemic.
For Covid-19, the airlines have mothballed their fleets and are riding out catastrophic financial losses. As Lauren Smith and Troy Hayes above suggest, maybe now is the time to invest in saving their brands.
Quite simply, saving a brand means upgrading aircraft, dramatically improving travel protocols and selling the scheme to the public.
The airlines carried 924.4 million passengers in 2019, so the potential market is huge and eminently reachable. Will they bite?
Needed for Passenger Safety and Emotional Comfort:
1. Separation (either 6' distance or Plexiglass panels)
2. Face shields and masks.
3. Seat upholstery and carpet disinfectants.
4. Frequently sanitized loos.
5. Double/triple air filtration.
6. A Swag Bag of PPE and protective goodies.
Prowling the Internet for Current Thinking (OUCH!)
I stumbled across the above rendering on Google.
This is separation at its most austere—a 21st century version of a Bauhaus interior. Sterile, cold, harsh and impersonal.
• What a gawdawful environment! Imagine these surroundings for 6 hours flying across country or 23 hours straight from Chicago to Singapore!
• Further, it puts airline profitability in extremis—way too much separation for far too few passengers.
Three Possible Safe-seating Configurations
1.
High Plexiglass back-screens to separate rows and ward off sneezes,
hawked lungers and baby brats hanging off the seat tops. Here three people would be scrunched cheek-by-jowl with no separation devices. The refit would cost the airline killer
amounts of money per plane while individual passengers are still endangered.
2. No pricey cabin redesign. Seats sprayed prior to take-off. Plexiglass back screens installed atop existing standard three-across seats will diminish the danger of sneezes, the hawking of lungers and oh-so-cute babies. However, the middle seat is eliminated with a Plexiglass separation panel, seriously reducing passenger count and profitability.
3. Existing seats (à la version 2) with two Plexiglass panels efficiently separating three passengers. If two people are traveling together, the panel between could be removed.
Let’s say the airlines' sphincter-tight
bean-counters agree to invest in the low-cost merger
of illustrations #2 & #3 above.
Their mantra would be that of Kevin
Costner: “Build it and they will come.”
“Build it and they will come is bullshit,” said Willard Rouse, developer of Boston’s Faneuil Hall Market restoration and Baltimore’s Inner Harbor. “Build it, sell the hell out of it and they will come!”
The Challenge of
Selling the Public
As a marketeer, I always try to
put myself inside the heads of my prospects—think how they think, feel what
they feel. Actually I BECOME my prospect. What would I say to me? What
would sell me—on travel in a commercial jet?
Here are the protocols I think I could live with (and hopefully not die from):
Face Shield, Mask and Swag Bag
(NOTE: With face shield, it's possible to push mask below chin for intake of food and drink. Not exactly gracious dining, but life sustaining.)
• Remember, I am paying the airline a $100 Pandemic Supplement on top of my airfare, so I should expect a bunch of goodies.
• Okay, here's the drill: I arrive at PHL via limo, Uber, taxi, family car or bus. I am stopped and required to show boarding passes. Guard puts a check mark on the paperwork and returns it to me along with face shield and mask. These must be donned prior to entering the airport interior.
• At some point during check-in we are each handed a travel kit:
If airline bean counters nix Denny's low-cost
seating modifications...
Plan B: Hand out all of the
above plus a sturdy, lightweight PPE isolation gown.
Takeaways to
Consider
• The above may represent the future
of air travel. Yuck.
• BTW, also the future of train and bus travel.
• If I walked into a crowded airport where everyone was wearing a face shield and mask, I do believe I would indeed feel a helluva lot safer flying out to a family emergency.
• Is the above sufficient to persuade Peggy and me to take a pleasure trip? NFW.
• I would like to postpone an eternity without vodka for as long as possible.
Dear Readers... Your Input and
Ideas Are Wanted!
• What ideas can you add?
• What have I missed or got wrong?
• Your critique of this post—pro or
anti?
Thank you.
###
Word count: 1008
Cool it, bro! You're not ready to fly. Profit margins on a regular full flight are slim at best. And, BTW, what is Troy Hayes phone number? HAGD Reg
ReplyDeleteReg, thanks for commenting.
Delete>> Cool it, bro! You're not ready to fly.<<
Sometimes ya gotta fly. (e.g. family emergency on the other coast)
>>Profit margins on a regular full flight are slim at best.<<
The extra $100 Pandemic Supplement should help some.
>> Troy Hayes phone number?<<
Go to https://theaviationagency.com and fill out the form at the bottom. Somebody should get back to you…
unless everybody’s gone ;-)
Cheers.
You neglected to include thoughts and comments about taking Amtrak instead of flying.
ReplyDeleteThank you for taking the time to comment.
DeleteI mentioned these new protocols may well be in the future of train and bus travel.
Personally I love trains. Am currently reading Pacific Crucible: War in the Pacific by Ian W. Toll. He tells the story of Admiral Nimitz, Chief of Naval Operations who had worked for 3 weeks straight—with meals at his desk and minimal sleep—after the sneak attack on Pearl Harbor. He was mentally wiped out. He was scheduled to go out to Pearl to see the damage and said okay, but he was going from Washington to Los Angeles by train just so he could get some sleep. The detailed description of the train trip—and Nimitz’s mental rehab was fascinating. Trains are wonderful in the here and in Europe. You get to see the country in ways you don’t see it flying over it or driving through it. Most working folks are too busy for long train trips.
BTW, if you want one of the best political books I have ever read, get Whistle Stop by Philip White—the story of Harry Truman against all odds winning re-election in 1948 by embarking on a 31,000-mile train trip where he made 352 speeches. He was under the radar. Pollsters ignored him. When he won, nobody could believe it!
Thanks again for writing. Do keep in touch!
I think those plexiglass dividers need to be rethought--although I confess I don't have a better idea. In about 3 months, they're going to be as scratched, dirty, and sticker-covered as those in your local gas station. Particularly under the notably lax cleaning regimes practiced by the airlines.
ReplyDeleteMark, Great point! Really glad you raised the question! I mentioned to Peggy that I thought the separators could be solids—non-see-thru plywood or plastic. When I’m on a plane next to a stranger, I would be just as happy not being aware of him/her. Peggy thought this scheme would be like blinders on a race horse which keep it focused on the track ahead. Cold, impersonal. In short, this could be tested followed by user surveys. But thank you, thank for taking the time to think this through and call me on it. Do keep in touch!
DeleteYou have an emergency and have to fly. Shields, masks, vitamin C drops, gloves and other protective gear do not answer the danger question. The recirculated air on the plane causes the problem. Yet giving everyone an oxygen tank probably would but prove expensive. Best to limit plane capacity. Don't go for the big buck so quickly. Keep the people in the flying habit by guaranteeing limited capacity. Fewer people, fewer breaths, fewer Covid consumers. Offer the various mask kits and keep prices semi-fair. Wait it out. They'll come back.
ReplyDeleteJeffrey, Great addition to the discussion! Good thinking. Thank You! Do keep in touch!
DeleteI can't think of a circumstance that would get me on a plane. But if I did, it would be on Delta with no middle seat occupied, good cleaning regime, and most importantly high re-circulation of HEPA filtered air, with fellow passengers wearing masks. Much safer than dining indoors.
ReplyDelete